Finding the best undercounter ice makers means balancing capacity, size, and convenience. The EUHOMY Commercial Ice Maker stands out as the overall top pick thanks to its high capacity and durability. For those seeking faster ice production, the Coolake Commercial Ice Maker offers impressive 200 lbs per day. Meanwhile, the EdgeStar IB450SSP shines with its clear ice quality and built-in drain pump. Each option comes with tradeoffs—larger models may take up more space, while smaller units might produce less ice. Continue reading for a detailed breakdown to help you find the perfect fit for your space and needs.
Key Takeaways
- High-capacity models like Coolake excel in busy environments but may be bulkier for small spaces.
- Ice quality varies; clear ice makers like EdgeStar produce more refined ice, ideal for beverages.
- Built-in drain pumps simplify maintenance but add to upfront costs and complexity.
- Size and installation flexibility matter; freestanding and built-in options serve different setups.
- Price often correlates with capacity and features—know what tradeoffs are acceptable for your budget.
More Details on Our Top Picks
EUHOMY Commercial Ice Maker Machine, 100lbs/24H Stainless Steel Under Counter Ice Machine with 33lbs Ice Storage
This model stands out for its impressive capacity, producing up to 100 pounds of clear ice daily, making it well-suited for both large households and small commercial setups. Unlike the EdgeStar IB450SSP, which offers less storage and a smaller daily output, the EUHOMY provides a significant advantage for users needing a continuous ice supply without frequent refilling. Its stainless steel build ensures durability, and the LCD control panel simplifies operation and cleaning. The main tradeoff involves installation complexity—requiring a floor drain and keeping the unit upright for 24 hours before use—making it less ideal for quick setup or spaces without drainage access.
Pros:- High capacity and rapid ice production
- Durable stainless steel construction
- Intuitive LCD control panel with cleaning function
Cons:- Requires floor drain for proper operation
- No included pump for drainage, complicating setup
- Initial placement needs upright standing for 24 hours
Best for: Large households, restaurants, or bars requiring high-volume ice production with durable build quality
Not ideal for: Small kitchens or users seeking a portable, plug-and-play ice maker without drainage requirements
- Ice Production Capacity:100 lbs per 24 hours
- Ice Cube Size:Adjustable via LCD panel
- Ice Storage Capacity:33 lbs
- Material:Stainless steel
- Cooling System:Efficient compressor
- Drainage:Gravity drain required
- Certification:ETL certified
Bottom line: This pick is ideal for users who need a powerful, high-capacity ice maker and are prepared for the installation demands.
Coolake Commercial Ice Maker 200 lbs/24H, Under Counter Ice Machine with 55 lbs Ice Storage, Air Cooled, Stainless Steel
The Coolake produces a hefty 200 pounds of ice daily, easily surpassing the EUHOMY and making it suitable for busy bars or restaurants needing a steady supply. Its self-cleaning feature extends longevity, and the stainless steel exterior guarantees durability, comparable to the EUHOMY’s build quality. However, unlike the EUHOMY, it’s heavier and bulkier, potentially requiring dedicated space and careful planning for installation. Customer ratings are only average, which suggests some users might encounter issues with reliability or support. Nonetheless, for those prioritizing volume and durability, this model offers significant advantages.
Pros:- Exceptional daily ice capacity of 200 lbs
- Self-cleaning for maintenance ease
- Durable stainless steel construction
Cons:- Heavy and requires ample space for installation
- Average customer ratings suggest potential reliability issues
Best for: Business owners managing high-volume needs, such as bars or cafes with a busy demand for ice
Not ideal for: Small households or users with limited space, due to its weight and size
- Production Capacity:200 lbs/24H
- Ice Storage Capacity:55 lbs
- Ice Cube Size:0.8-inch dice
- Cooling System:Air-cooled
- Material:Stainless steel
- Dimensions:Not specified
- Weight:60.63 pounds
Bottom line: Ideal for commercial settings where high output and durability are priorities over portability.
EdgeStar IB450SSP 50 lb. Undercounter Clear Ice Maker with Drain Pump
This model is tailored for users who prefer large sheets of clear ice, producing 50 pounds daily, which is ideal for upscale drinks or presentation needs. Compared to the EUHOMY, which focuses on cubed ice, the EdgeStar’s sheet ice offers a more refined aesthetic but requires breaking apart for individual use, adding a prep step. Its internal drain pump simplifies installation, especially in settings where drainage might be tricky. However, the ice melts faster because it’s in sheets, and it doesn’t function as a freezer, so ice must be used relatively quickly. It’s best suited for those who value presentation over convenience in ice handling.
Pros:- Produces large quantities of clear sheet ice daily
- Internal drain pump simplifies installation
- Built-in durability with stainless steel construction
Cons:- Ice needs to be broken apart, adding prep time
- No freezer function, ice melts over time
Best for: Bars or restaurants needing large, clear sheet ice for cocktails and display
Not ideal for: Users seeking cubed or nugget ice, or those looking for frozen, longer-lasting ice
- Ice Production:50 lbs per day
- Ice Storage:25 lbs
- Ice Type:Sheet ice
- Drain Pump:Yes
- Material:Commercial-grade stainless steel
- Dimensions:32.8″ H x 15″ W x 23.6″ D
- Weight:76.7 pounds
Bottom line: This is best for venues that prioritize visual appeal and large sheet ice over everyday convenience.
Under Counter Ice Maker, 95 lbs/Day with 35 lbs Storage, Reversible Door, Built-in Commercial Ice Machine
This model produces nearly as much ice as the 200-pound Coolake, but with added flexibility thanks to its reversible door and built-in design. Its rapid 10-minute cycle creates 40 cubes, making it well-suited for busy environments that need quick replenishment. Compared to the EUHOMY, which is more focused on simple household use, this unit offers more customization and convenience features, though it might require professional installation due to its built-in nature. The energy consumption could be high for continuous operation, so it’s better suited for spaces where efficiency is less critical than speed and flexibility.
Pros:- High daily production of 95 lbs
- Fast 10-minute ice cycle
- Reversible door for flexible installation
Cons:- Requires professional installation under counter
- Potentially high energy use with prolonged operation
Best for: Commercial or busy home environments needing quick, high-volume ice production with installation flexibility
Not ideal for: Small kitchens or users seeking portable, standalone units without installation complexity
- Ice Production:95 lbs per day
- Storage Capacity:35 lbs
- Ice Cube Size:Customizable via ice thickness
- Production Time:40 cubes in 10 minutes
- Reversible Door:Yes
- Built-in Design:Yes
- Self-Cleaning:Yes
Bottom line: Best suited for settings demanding rapid ice generation combined with flexible installation options.
Undercounter Nugget Ice Maker, Commercial Ice Machine, 66 lbs/Day, Built-in or Freestanding, Self-Cleaning, Stainless Steel
This compact nugget ice maker offers a solid 66 pounds of chewable ice daily, making it an excellent choice for bars, cafes, or small restaurants. Its quick production cycle, typically within 10-15 minutes, rivals larger models like the Coolake but with a smaller footprint—though it still requires a fair amount of space. Its quiet operation and self-cleaning feature add convenience for continuous use. Compared to the EUHOMY, which excels at cubed ice, this nugget model provides a different experience, perfect for customers who prefer softer, chewable ice. The main consideration is its size, which may be too large for tight spaces, and the necessity of a water connection.
Pros:- Produces 66 lbs of nugget ice daily
- Fast production cycle of 10-15 minutes
- Quiet operation and self-cleaning
Cons:- Large size may require ample space
- Requires water connection for operation
Best for: Bars, cafes, or businesses needing quick, chewable ice with minimal noise
Not ideal for: Small kitchens or users without enough space or water hookup capacity
- Dimensions:15 x 18.03 x 32.48 inches
- Ice Production:66 lbs per 24 hours
- Ice Type:Nugget ice
- Material:Stainless steel
- Self-Cleaning:Yes
- Water Supply:Automatic water intake pipe
Bottom line: This nugget ice maker suits commercial venues that prioritize quick, chewable ice in a compact form.
EdgeStar IB250 15-Inch Wide Freezer and Ice Maker with 20 Lb. Capacity and 25 Lb. Daily Production
The EdgeStar IB250 stands out as a versatile choice for those who need both ice and freezing capabilities in a single unit. Its ability to produce 25 pounds of crescent-shaped ice daily and store up to 20 pounds makes it suitable for busy households or small commercial settings. Unlike the smaller, more basic options, this model’s dual functionality and reversible door provide flexible installation options. However, its bulkier size means it may not fit in tight spaces, and some users report inconsistent ice production, which could be a concern for frequent use. Compared to the Manitowoc UDF0140A, it offers less ice capacity but more versatility, especially for those needing a combined freezer and ice maker.
Pros:- Produces a substantial amount of ice daily
- Reversible door for flexible installation
- No drain line required for operation
- Includes essential accessories like ice scoop and water line
Cons:- Customer rating is only 3.1 out of 5 stars, indicating mixed reviews
- Bulkier size may require ample space
- Some users report inconsistent ice production
Best for: Homeowners or small business owners needing a multi-purpose appliance with decent storage and production capacity
Not ideal for: Kitchens with limited space or those seeking a dedicated, high-capacity ice maker only
- Ice Production:25 lbs. per day
- Ice Storage Capacity:20 lbs.
- Dimensions:14.9″ W x 20.06″ D x 33.31″ H
- Ice Shape:Crescent-shaped
- Material:Stainless Steel
- Included Components:Ice scoop, water line, removable ice bin
Bottom line: This pick suits those wanting a versatile, space-efficient unit that combines ice-making and freezing but may require patience with its performance variability.
Icyglee Commercial Under Counter Ice Maker Machine with Drain Pump, 100Lbs/Day, 24Lbs Storage, Self-Cleaning, 24H Timer, Stainless Steel
The Icyglee Commercial Ice Maker delivers impressive capacity, producing up to 100 pounds of ice daily, making it ideal for busy venues or large households. Its LCD panel allows for precise control, including adjustable cube thickness, a feature not available on most smaller models like the EdgeStar IB250. Its self-cleaning function adds to convenience, but the requirement for proper drainage means installation might be more complex. While it offers excellent output, the noise level can be higher during operation, and its size demands a dedicated space. This model’s high production capacity makes it a clear choice over smaller units for users needing bulk ice regularly.
Pros:- Produces up to 100 pounds of ice daily
- Automatic cleaning simplifies maintenance
- Adjustable cube thickness for beverage customization
- Compact design suitable for under counter or standalone use
Cons:- Requires proper drainage setup for optimal operation
- No specific power specifications provided, which could impact compatibility
- Potentially noisy during operation
Best for: Small commercial operators or large households needing high-volume ice production
Not ideal for: Those with limited space or seeking a quiet, low-profile unit for occasional use
- Ice Production:100 lbs per day
- Storage Capacity:24 lbs
- Dimensions:20.4″D x 14.96″W x 33.9″H
- Ice Cube Thickness Control:Yes
- Self-Cleaning:Yes
- Material:Stainless Steel
Bottom line: This model makes the most sense for high-demand environments where volume and convenience outweigh its installation complexity.
COTLIN 15-Inch Drainless Under Counter Ice Maker with 22LBS Storage, Crescent Ice, Free Standing or Built-in, ETL Certified, Upgraded 2026
The COTLIN 15-Inch Drainless Ice Maker offers a straightforward, reliable option with a 22-pound storage capacity and crescent-shaped ice designed to melt slowly, ideal for keeping drinks cooler longer. Its drainage-free design simplifies installation compared to models like the Icyglee that require drainage setup. While limited to crescent-shaped ice, this unit’s easy one-touch operation and ETL certification make it a solid choice for residential or light commercial use. Its size may be a tight fit under very low countertops, so measurement is key. Compared with multi-purpose units, it focuses solely on high-quality ice production, with a focus on user-friendly setup and safety.
Pros:- Produces high-quality crescent-shaped ice that melts slowly
- Drainage-free design for easy installation
- Large 22-pound ice storage capacity
- Reversible door and adjustable feet for flexible setup
Cons:- Limited to crescent-shaped ice only
- Requires water supply connection
- Size might not fit under very low countertops
Best for: Home users or small businesses wanting reliable crescent ice with minimal installation fuss
Not ideal for: Locations needing a variety of ice shapes or very large storage capacity
- Ice Shape:Crescent
- Storage Capacity:22 lbs
- Dimensions:14.9″W x 18.6″D x 33.8″H
- Temperature Range:26.6-32°F
- Certification:ETL
- Material:Brushed stainless steel
Bottom line: This model suits users prioritizing easy setup, reliable crescent ice, and flexible installation options over variety or very high capacity.
Manitowoc UDF0140A NEO 26″ Air Cooled Undercounter Dice Cube Ice Machine with 90 lb. Bin – 115V, 135 lb
The Manitowoc UDF0140A NEO excels as a commercial-grade solution with a robust 135-pound daily ice output and a generous 90-pound bin. Its focus on dice cube ice makes it ideal for hospitality settings requiring consistent, easy-to-serve ice. Unlike the smaller, less specialized EdgeStar or COTLIN units, this model emphasizes hygiene and maintenance, featuring integrated cleaning aids and a simple design for quick sanitation. Its heavier weight and specific 115V power requirement mean installation is more involved, but the investment pays off for high-volume, reliable ice production. This unit’s advanced features make it the best choice for busy commercial environments rather than casual home use.
Pros:- Produces up to 135 pounds of dice cube ice daily
- Easy-to-clean design with rounded corners and molded surfaces
- Hygiene features like Alphasan and LumLice inhibitors
- Includes a dishwasher-safe air filter for maintenance
Cons:- Heavy weight (150 lbs) requiring help during installation
- Limited to 115V power, not compatible everywhere
- Customer rating of 4.0/5 suggests some users encounter issues
Best for: Commercial settings such as restaurants or bars needing reliable, high-volume dice ice
Not ideal for: Home kitchens or spaces with limited power or assistance for heavy appliance installation
- Ice Production:135 lb per day
- Bin Capacity:90 lb
- Voltage:115V
- Weight:150 pounds
- Included Components:Undercounter Ice Machine
- Warranty:36 months (parts) + additional 24 months on compressor and evaporator
Bottom line: This machine is best for high-demand, professional environments where volume, hygiene, and durability are priorities over installation ease.
